Introduction to ICE’s Office of Professional Responsibility (OPR) and Its Role
The Office of Professional Responsibility (OPR) within the Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agency is primarily tasked with internal investigations, including inspections of detention facilities, employee misconduct investigations, and security clearance processing. However, recent court documents suggest that OPR is increasingly focusing on civilian cases involving doxing and threats directed towards ICE employees. This shift in focus has raised questions about the appropriateness of OPR’s involvement in such matters.
OPR’s Recent Investigations
Court documents indicate that between January 2025 and March 2026, OPR investigated 131 cases involving “incidents of doxing and threats directed towards ICE employees nationwide. ” While the number of resulting criminal charges is unclear, one instance where OPR’s investigative work was credited was in a case where the Justice Department accused a California man of harassing an ICE attorney and her mother. The man pleaded guilty to the charges, which were brought well before President Trump took office.
The Incident Involving Paigelynne Gonyea
In June 2022, during the state primaries in Syracuse, New York, ICE agents arrived at a polling site to investigate a poll worker named Paigelynne Gonyea. Gonyea, a Minnesota Star Tribune reporter, had made a post on Instagram crediting the newspaper for identifying Jonathan Ross, an ICE agent who shot and killed Renee Goodman during the federal incursion in Minneapolis. The agents were concerned about this post, which they believed could impede Ross’s work. They asked Gonyea to sign a warning notice that she would be held legally responsible for her post and to remove or cease her behavior. Gonyea refused to sign the notice, citing it as an admission of guilt. This incident highlights the potential misuse of OPR’s internal watchdog role.
Concerns About OPR’s Role
The use of OPR’s internal investigations for civilian cases has raised concerns. Laura Moraff, a staff attorney at the ACLU’s Speech, Privacy, and Technology Project, emphasizes that while there are limited circumstances where speech can be legally restricted, the First Amendment provides civilians with the right to criticize the government and engage in such activities online. The ACLU’s stance is that OPR’s actions are not in line with its intended role as an internal watchdog.
Administrative Subpoenas and Their Impact
In recent months, ICE has sent administrative subpoenas to tech companies, seeking information about online critics. One such subpoena, with a tracking number starting with “OPR-DC,” has been withdrawn. The source familiar with the agency confirms that this subpoena is likely related to OPR’s efforts. The withdrawal of the subpoena underscores the potential misuse of OPR’s authority in civilian cases.
Conclusion
The increasing involvement of OPR in civilian cases, particularly those involving doxing and threats, raises significant concerns about the agency’s role and the potential misuse of its internal watchdog status. As the agency continues to expand its definition of doxing to include lawful activities, the balance between internal oversight and civilian privacy remains a critical issue. The recent actions of OPR highlight the need for clear guidelines and oversight to ensure that the agency’s internal investigations are appropriately confined to its intended scope of responsibilities.

Comments