The Cancelled Batgirl Project: A $90 Million Investment That Never Saw the Light of Day
Hollywood's history of canceling movies is well-documented, but the cancellation of a $90 million superhero film by Warner Bros. Discovery is a rare and unusual occurrence. Batgirl, a DC movie featuring Leslie Grace as Barbara Gordon and J. Simmons as her father Jim Gordon, was one such case. The film was initially slated for release, but Warner Bros. Discovery ultimately decided not to release it, leaving the project shelved and potentially at risk of being destroyed.
Batgirl had already been in development for years, with Joss Whedon initially hired to write and direct the project in 2017. However, he left in 2018 due to story development issues. Christina Hodson was then brought in to write a new screenplay, and the project eventually moved forward with Adil El Arbi and Bilall Fallah directing. The film had been in post-production when Warner Bros. Discovery announced in August 2022 that it would not be released in theaters or on HBO Max.
The Budget and Production
The initial budget for Batgirl was reported to be around $70 million, but it eventually grew to roughly $90 million. Filming took place in Glasgow, Scotland, from November 2021 until March 2022, before the movie entered post-production. The project had been made for streaming, but its budget reached theatrical-release levels, complicating its release strategy.
The Proposed Storyline
The Batgirl plot was never officially released, but a Reddit post compiled details from several sources offered a rumored idea of what the story contained. The plot reportedly began with Barbara Gordon, a young girl, watching Batman save her father after criminals nearly killed him. The story then jumps to an adult Barbara working at the GCPD, where she deals with the death of her mother, who was killed in a fire. Barbara eventually becomes interested in becoming a vigilante and uses her photographic memory to study fighting techniques and investigate cases at the GCPD. The story also reportedly involved Anthony Bressi, the son of a Gotham crime boss, and Barbara's relationships with her close friends, Jason Bard and Alysia Yeoh. Anthony's connection to Gotham's criminal underworld eventually puts him on the opposite side of Barbara.
The Decision to Cancel
Despite a strong rumored story premise, Warner Bros. The studio chose to take a tax write-off on the project as part of its plan to cut billions of dollars in costs. Reports suggest negative reactions to a test screening played a role in the decision. However, this seems unlikely, given that Batgirl had only been shown to the public once, and the film was still unfinished with temporary visual effects and a temporary score.
The Future of the Footage
Since directors Adil El Arbi and Bilall Fallah said they didn't have access to the footage, Batgirl will never get a chance to have the equivalent of a Zack Snyder's Justice League release. eventually held private screenings for people who worked on the movie. According to The Hollywood Reporter, releasing Batgirl after taking a tax write-off could create problems for the studio's ability to claim the write-off, as the movie could potentially generate revenue in the future. There was even speculation that Warner Bros. might destroy the footage to prove it could never make money, although other sources disputed this would be necessary.
Conclusion
Discovery's decision to cancel Batgirl before release represents a rare and unusual case in Hollywood's history of movie cancellations. The project's cancellation leaves the film shelved and potentially at risk of being destroyed, highlighting the challenges faced by studios in balancing budget, audience expectations, and streaming strategies.

Comments