Introduction

When it comes to eGPUs, there are essentially two mainstream ways to connect them to a PC: Thunderbolt or USB4, which is the standard for most laptops and handheld PCs. In this article, I will compare the performance and convenience of using Oculink, a less convenient but potentially high-performance method, with Thunderbolt.

I tested my eGPU with Oculink and Thunderbolt, and it wasn’t close

Setup

I used an ASRock RX 9070 Challenger as my GPU of choice for the tests. The 9070 was connected via Oculink in a PCIe 3. 0 x4 interface, while the second setup used a standard Thunderbolt 3 interface. The results were quite surprising, with Oculink offering more than just raw performance.

Testing and Results

I tested each system with gaming benchmarks and engaged in some day-to-day use. The results were quite surprising, with Oculink being a far more performant solution, and Thunderbolt just doesn’t come close. This was very apparent in the case of Doom: The Dark Ages, where the 5600G PC maintained a higher average frame rate with the same RX 9070 as the Strix Halo machine. The Strix Halo device barely managed a stable 60 frames per second in comparison.

Performance and Stability

The cause of the difference in performance was bottlenecking. We are nowhere near the PCIe bandwidth of the Thunderbolt connection, and Oculink has no issues keeping up. The sleep/wake functionality also worked seamlessly with Oculink, while Thunderbolt often resulted in a system crash. In terms of performance, Oculink connections tend to be much more stable, with fewer frame-rate dips and frame-time stutters.

Limitations and Considerations

Despite its superior performance and stability, Oculink has one fatal flaw: it is not designed to be plugged and unplugged often. The connector is brittle and has latches to hold it in place. This is perhaps why it also lacks hotplug functionality. In other words, you cannot unplug and replug a GPU using Oculink when a system is up and running. Thunderbolt, on the other hand, is a lot more convenient to use, especially for thin and light laptops with decent CPUs.

Conclusion

If you're looking for something more consistent, Oculink might be your only choice, but it does have one fatal flaw. Thunderbolt, despite its performance loss, is a lot more convenient to use. It is also a lot cheaper to get into, especially for mini PCs or devices that won’t see much movement. However, for those who prioritize convenience and portability, Thunderbolt is the better choice.

Comments